Exclusive: Is the ADA Dropping its Corporate Sponsors?

UPDATE: See ADA’s response below.

We’ve just learned from several dietitians about an online survey the American Dietetic Association is circulating among its 70,000 strong membership, focusing on RDs attitudes about the organization’s corporate sponsorship program. You know – taking money from big food companies and pretending it doesn’t matter. Current sponsors include The Coca Cola Company, PepsiC0, Mars, Hershey -  purveyors of healthy foods and beverages that make America the healthiest, slimmest nation in the world…

From the survey:

  • Are you aware that ADA has a Corporate Relations Sponsorship program? Yes/No
  • Would you say, knowing that an organization or brand is an ADA Partner or Premier Sponsor, that you would feel that they are an organization or brand you would value … More / Less / No different … than other organizations or brands?

Some of the questions seem a bit loaded:

How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?

  • The Coca-Cola Company promotes ADA members as the experts when it comes to helping people eat well and stay healthy.
  • The Coca-Cola Company has taken a leadership role in communicating information about beverage science and innovation, as well as educating consumers about factual, science-based nutrition information.

Who cares? The point is it should not be a sponsor.

It’s a lengthy survey that seems to be doing everything it can to explain the benefits of the partnerships. Thankfully though, it does conclude with a clear question on the sponsorship issue:

From what you know, how do you feel about ADA’s Corporate Relations Sponsorship program in general?
Strongly approve / Somewhat approve / No opinion / unsure / Somewhat disapprove / Strongly disapprove

What you need to know:

Fooducate’s position is well known. Taking money from Coke, PepsiCo, and Hershey portends serious credibility issues for the organization. Many RDs agree and we’re glad enough of them have raised a red flag that has led to this survey. Hopefully the results will lead to an ADA policy change.

The funny thing is that all the sponsorship money adds up to less than 10% of the ADA’s total funding. With a little “kvetch” and some creativity, the ADA can easily overcome this and feel more free than ever to give clear cut advice such as:

Skip the soft drinks. Drink Tap water. Eat a bag of chips once a month. Dark chocolate is good, one tiny square a day at most. Moderation means a rare treat, not a daily snack….

We have emailed the ADA and are hoping to hear directly from them on the matter.

Here is the response we got from ADA Media Relations Manager Ryan O’Malley:

Thank you for the opportunity to respond to your posting regarding ADA’s Corporate Sponsorship program. This is actually the fourth consecutive year that ADA has sent a Corporate Sponsor Survey to a sampling of active ADA members. We work with an outside firm to develop and deploy the survey and analyze the results, which are then shared with ADA leadership as well as the respective sponsors.

The purpose of this survey is to receive objective feedback and gauge attitudes and perceptions with regard to ADA’s Corporate Relations Sponsorship program and ADA Partners and Premier Sponsors.

To reiterate, ADA closely evaluates all potential sponsorships to ensure that they are consistent with ADA’s science-based positions and messages. ADA does not endorse any companies, products or services. Sponsors do not influence the Association’s decision making process nor do they affect policy positions.

If this is the 4th year the survey is running, how many more will be required until something changes?

Get Fooducated: iPhone App RSS Subscription or Email Subscription

Follow us on twitter: twitter.com/fooducate on facebook: facebook.com/fooducate

Get Fooducated

  • http://www.betterschoolfood.org Dr. Susan Rubin

    Wouldn’t it be great if the School Nutrition Association did the same thing? They take money from the food industry as well.

  • Joyce Shanks

    Integrity is of the utmost importance when educating people, it seems hypocritical to teach people about wholesome goodness and promote and support those who do the opposite. I truly hope that changes occur soon.

  • http://www.rochesternutrition.com Carol Plotkin

    There are many dietitians who have dropped their ADA membership because of these partnerships. Too bad they won’t be included in the survey results.

  • http://newmexicodietitian.wordpress.com Shelley Rael

    They did a very similar survey a year or so ago. You should ask them for the results of that one.

  • Mary

    @Carol Plotkin
    Carol, I am one of them! I’ll be interested to see what comes of this survey. I’m glad at they are asking the opinions of their members!

  • http://www.thefrugaldietitian.com Nancy-The Frugal Dietitian

    I dropped mine Carol 2 years ago (after 30+ years of membership) and I must admit I still promote the organization because they still have wonderful members and ideals. But there are also RDs, members and not, who I would never recommend due to their teachings and beliefs due to lack of evidence based practices. But it doesn’t mean I am against all RDs. Personally, I don’t think the average consumer is even aware that these companies are sponsors. Being frugal, I couldn’t justify spending the yearly dues which for me was over $300 – cost vs benefit.

  • http://foodtrainers.blogspot.com Lauren Slayton

    I love that they’re even asking for opinion on this, maybe the “nudging” has made a difference. Let’s see what happens.

  • http://julikeene.com Juli Keene, CN

    @Dr. Susan Rubin
    I agree. thank you!

  • http://www.FeedingTheKids.com Ellie Taylor

    There are many ways that food companies manipulate schools, hospitals, organizations and KIDS with money. Just heard an ad urging kids to collect boxtops from General Mills Cereal to win equipment for their schools. Our local McDonalds has “McTeachers” nights where the principal and teachers cook fries, and families go there to eat so their school gets a percent of sales. We need to vilify these connections between big food and innocent consumers. And I do hope that the ADA and other organizations (including nonprofits like American Heart and Cancer) will understand that their goals and the goals of big food corporations are in direct conflict.

  • Diane Beere

    Thank goodness and with much hope for success in dropping sponsors like Coca Cola, Pepsi, and Hershey. Ten percent seems slight in the big picture nonetheless its similarity to the one rotten apple wreaking havoc in the apple cart let’s us know how damaging that ten percent can be. Accepting their sponsorship can’t help but have a pernicious effect on ADA’s goals.

  • Dawn

    Interestingly enough, I have been a member of the ADA for years and I was not included or aware of this survey! I would like to see termination of these sponsors with the ADA, too bad my vote will not be counted for.

  • http://www.UrbanOrganicGardener.com Mike Lieberman

    There is a huge conflict of interest when companies selling products are sponsoring the people who are supposed to be reviewing them. How is this not seen?

  • Holly

    I was included in the survey — and I strongly disapproved of the sponsors. I’m not an RD yet, I’m a grad student getting my MS in Nutrition, after which I’ll do the intership and sit the exam. I’m trying to keep a positive attitude for now and hope that by being a member who is clearly and vocally against sponsorship I can help the organization change by the time I do become an RD. This is my future profession, and I know these partnerships have a negative influence on the reputation of RDs (I’ve seen comments on blogs by lay people who care about nutrition saying things like, “I’d never trust an RD, they’re bought an paid for by Hersheys and Pepsico”), so I’m really concerned about this.

  • Windy Daley

    Audrae Erickson, chiel lobbyist for the Corn Refiners Association, constantly quotes the American Dietetic Association as positive towards high fructose corn syrup. The ADA is a joke, and a threat to the health of this nation. The corporate sponsors of the ADA are a perfect example of what is wrong with this country. Who would trust a dietition who is a member of this organization? I don’t want health information from the cold drink and processed snack companies. I’m surprised that the tobacco companies are not sponsors–or are they (in some hidden form)? If someone brags that they are from the American Dietetic Association–run for your life, and your health.

  • Ashley

     Our Dietetic Practice Group within ADA did our own Corporate Sponsorship survey. They results show overwhelming concern by RD’s related to the types of corporate sponsors our professional organization partners with. There was recently a break off of ADA of members who are fed up. I have the result and more information if that is of interest for a follow up story.  if that is of interest for a follow up story. 

    • http://www.fooducate.com/blog Fooducate

      Ashely – We’re interested in learning more please email us blog at fooducate dot com

    • Sarah Heiss, PhD

       Ashley. Could you tell me more about your survey results? Were they published? sheiss at uvm dot com