I’m a QUALITARIAN. Why You Should Be One Too

This is a guest blog post by Ashley Koff, RD

For years, people would routinely pose the same question me “so what are you?” Pretty sure that people are clear that I’m a brunette, a female, even that I’m a dietitian (though sometimes they confuse that with a nutritionist – sorry folks, I have a license and years of education plus internship to show for it).

Since the question usually came amidst a conversation about food choices, I would presume they were asking about my eating habits. And for years, I wouldn’t really have an answer.

I had been a vegan, a pesco-tarian, a person following a macrobiotic diet and later Westin Price’s protocol; I had dabbled with Atkins out of curiosity (and the promise of daily lattes with half and half), the Body Ecology diet (despite not having a yeast problem, call it ‘professional curiosity’) as well as other “plans”.

So the question was about my eating for sure, but I also realized that it came with undertones. Obviously if I, as a nutrition expert, was eating in a certain fashion, that must be the plan I endorsed for others.

It got me thinking – what protocol or plan do I endorse?

A few years ago I had the good fortune to vacation, truly vacation – as in no cellular service once we hit the seventeen miles of dirt road that took me to the ranch, as in no cell service while I was casting, wading, or glaring at the bank in search of snakes, and as in not eating a single thing from a package.

During that trip, a ranch hand cooked dinner for me one night, a fly fishing guide brought me lunch daily, and a group of women invited me to their gathering where I sampled some of their amazing treats. Yet, I was in Montana – and in Montana they eat meat, and not just meat but game.

I haven’t eaten meat in 15 years after a rather memorable experience with some veins in a supposed chicken breast in my college campus café almost sent me right into the hands of my frozen yogurt-loving, bin-food candy eating friends. While that didn’t work out to well as fuel for college requiring energy, the no meat part lasted.

But back to Montana. At first I declined to eat antelope, to taste bison, or try any other meat. I said no to the dairy from the cow whom I could see eating the grass just outside the window. Then, someone said to me “so what’s your objection? Is it animal cruelty, taste, or what they might be fed, cause I can tell you I treat these animals like they are my kids – no hormones, plenty of grass…” and then he chuckled and looked at his grown son “and I do kill them when it’s time – I guess that’s where it’s a little different than my kids.”

“So what was my objection,” I pondered.

I object to animals fed food they wouldn’t eat in nature, to the medications used to treat them when they develop illness related to eating the wrong foods; I object to artificial ingredients, chemical combinations made in a lab to look like things in nature but that don’t chemically resemble what’s in nature. I object to genetic modification of plants (and certainly of animals) so that we can speed growth up or get more of something when what nature provides should be plenty. And I object to making claims about components of foods when one doesn’t have anything nice (or worthy) to say about the rest of the food or product. Thus, I realized, I had no objection, other than what my palate may or may not enjoy, to the meat being presented to me in Montana. It was quality food.

And so, “Qualitarianism” was born.

Being a qualitarian, is, I believe, the solution to our health issues today – all of them. We wouldn’t have the quantity and intensity of health issues (mental and physical) if we ate better quality foods exclusively.  And if we all ate better quality foods, they would cost less resulting from greater demand for food coupled with lesser need for advertising money to be spent to counter the poor quality food products. If we all ate better quality food, better quality food would be more available, too.

What does it mean to be a qualitarian?

It means, first and foremost, that you choose to be the gatekeeper for what goes into your body. That you don’t feel deprived but rather empowered when you turn down a veggie burger with genetically engineered ingredients or hexane and rather enjoy one made from organic quinoa and mushrooms or a wild salmon burger or a grass-fed burger.

It also means saying no to a ready-to-eat salad of chemically sprayed lettuces in favor of cooking your own organic broccoli (great to start with frozen too).

And it means taking pride in being smarter than the front of a package or a commercial. Yes, you are smarter than both of those; yes, you are. You are smarter than the package that tells you what it wants you to know but doesn’t tell you the rest of the story.

There are so many amazing resources out there today to help you on the journey to becoming a qualitarian. I have added one more – the Ashley Koff Approved lists – so that if you don’t know what questions to ask, don’t have the time, energy, or even don’t care to do the work, you can feel comfortable that I have asked the questions and have evaluated the products for you. Why should you trust me? Because I became and remain a registered dietitian to address my curiosity, which can be at times relentless, about what is actually good quality in our food system. That, and because I am not paid to evaluate any products – the Ashley Koff Approved stamp of nutrition for optimal health can’t be bought, it’s earned.

I hope you will join me in becoming a qualitarian and please email me (aka@ashleykoffapproved.com) questions and follow me on facebook at the Ashley Koff Approved fan page or on Twitter @ashleykoff for daily tips and discoveries on being a qualitarian.

Ashley Koff RD, founder of Ashley Koff approved (AKA), the stamp of optimal nutrition, is your go-to source for any questions about food, dietary supplements, why and how to be a Qualitarian. Seen regularly in such media outlets such as The Huffington Post, Good Morning America Health, E! News, O! The Oprah Magazine, Redbook and Glamour, Koff is the resident nutritionist for the upcoming CW’s “Shedding for the Wedding.”

Get Fooducated: iPhone App RSS Subscription or Email Subscription

Follow us on twitter: twitter.com/fooducate on facebook: facebook.com/fooducate

Get Fooducated

  • Ruth

    I don’t disagree with anything you say, but isn’t a qualitarian just the same as following the ideas of Weston A. Price? On the other hand, if you can open anyone’s eyes to the fact that we need to eat real, nutrient dense, high quality food, then I’m a fan.

  • http://stayhealthy-livewell.com Monica Reinagel

    Qualitarian–I love it! A fun new spin on the real/whole food movement.

    Just had to leave a quick comment, though. I AM a nutritionist (not a dietitian) and I ALSO have a state license, years of education (including a Master’s of Science in Nutrition), supervised training hours, and ADA affiliation to show for it. I have the greatest respect for my RD colleagues and although I understand the mistrust of nutritionists (many who call themselves nutritionists do NOT have the same education and background), I think it’s time for all *qualified* nutrition professionals to work together respectfully to help educate others and improve public health instead of taking pot-shots at those who have different but equally valid professional backgrounds. Long live Qualitarianism!

  • Jessica

    Really enjoyed this article as someone who was a pescatarian for 6 months and felt “hungry” the whole time. Now I would like to think my diet could be considered “qualitarian.” I eat what I would like and what makes me feel good!

    Great guest blogger!

  • Amy

    I guess I have been a Qualitarian for 20 years. I hate going to resturants where the quality of food they serve is equal to or only slightly better than school cafeteria food. Therefore, we just don’t eat out too much. We raise our own beef, milk, chicken and pork. We trade our meat for veggies at local farmer’s markets, and sell the rest. It really does make a difference. And I find that when I slip and eat something pre-fabbed, then I feel lousy the next day. I think it really is worth the effort to find the best, highest quality food possible.One thing though, popular thinking of quality and true, old fashioned quality are two comepletely different things. Best example: dairy products. Pasturization just ruins cheese and other products. I think you have really hit upon a great new word. I will help you spread it around. Thanks!

  • http://k9-crazy.blogspot.com K9-CRAZY

    Great post & word that describes my “diet” quite well.

  • http://www.UrbanOrganicGardener.com Mike Lieberman

    I love it. It’s pretty much my philosophy. Personally I’m not a meat eater either, but have nothing against eating sustainably raised beef. The reason that I don’t eat meat anymore is that I don’t think if I could kill or see my food being killed in front of me.

  • http://urfatimnot.com manuel lusquinos

    While I respect the education & experience required of anyone who is a dietitian or nutritionist,I’m usually discouraged when I hear or read the advice that far too many of these credentialed experts give to people who are attempting to improve their health. The advice includes sugar, salt, alcohol & “treating yourself” with the exact type of food that you should not eat. Food is an addiction,habit,pass time etc. for out of shape & overweight people. They eat for all the wrong reasons. I wouldn’t, in that wishy washy way, advise a heroin addict to shoot up & “treat himself ” in moderation or to just avoid heroin,any more than I would advise an overweight individual to consume in moderation or just avoid soda , fast food & ice cream. I would suggest to both these individuals that they stop ingesting their respective vice forever. I suppose the finality of “forever” is what prevents most people from getting better. Too bad, because it works.

  • http://www.foodieformerlyfat.com Foodie, Formerly Fat

    This is a great post! I’m so glad I’ve found this blog! This is the same crusade I’m on. Quality in food consumption becomes health in the body. I’m no dietitian but I can see that for myself. When I eat well I am well. When I eat poorly I do poorly.

    While I see Manuel’s point, and I agree with it for people who truly have a food addiction, many people who eat poorly aren’t food addicts. Many are simply poorly educated on the issues of food and nutrition. We don’t learn about nutrition in school as a matter of course. Many people no longer learn how to cook from parents, grandparents, aunts and uncles, etc. Life in our American culture has become too chaotic to support cooking at home. And socioeconomics is a huge part of why some people are obese. Right now, healthy food is more expensive than the edible food like substances that are readily available.

    We have to work on making quality food affordable, accessible, and appealing in order to reverse this tide.

    I

  • http://www.sportfuel.com Jenny Westerkamp RD

    Manuel – I agree! I am a dietitian and am not a fan of “everything in moderation” and “every food fits”…the typical dietitian sayings. If we could educate our clients on WHY they should change their habits (what they don’t hear in the media and on commercials), then we wouldn’t have to take things so slowly with HOW to change their habits (motivational interviewing, counseling to make small, “realistic” changes, etc). I am a new dietitian in a sports nutrition/wellness private practice and still fine tuning my approach, but I find THE TRUTH behind the food industry can really empower people! It did for me!

    Ashley – what a great summary of a great philosophy. I am with you 100%!

  • Verena

    I agree with the qualitarian idea in general, however I have a question: is it normal for a cow to produce milk year round? I thought cow’s milk was for a calf and not produced all the time, only to suckle the young? Correct me if I’m wrong. But in that case I still wouldn’t want a cow’s milk even if it was grass-fed.

  • http://foodtrainers.blogspot.com Lauren Slayton

    Leave it to Ashley, so well said and explained. Funny though, I have an MS and am an RD and prefer the term nutritionist to dietitian, the latter reminds me of my hospital time and a lab coat a far dry from what I do today. Hmn.

  • charlotte

    I’m just a bit baffled as to why society feels the need to place a label on everything, including our eating habits. Will that in and of itself, constitute a preconceived prejudice about someone? Seems like we’re all grouping ourselves into a “food politics” debacle, which is exactly the LAST thing we need to be doing right now. People consciously either live to eat or eat to live -how the heck did it all become so convoluted??

  • Carrie

    @Monica Reinagel
    I’m Green with envy

  • http://urfatimnot.com manuel lusquinos

    Foodie, I agree with you that many people who eat poorly aren’t food addicts. The most precious gift we possess is our health, but one would never know this by the ignorance, with regards to nutrition/fitness ,in society today. Nutrition/fitness education should be a required course of study in our schools. While I am a strong proponent of overall education, memorizing the names of people long ago dead and dates of significant events, will not help us live long, healthy and fit lives. Knowledge of nutrition/fitness seems to me to be more important. I however,will not hold my breath waiting for mandatory nutrition/fitness education. If it’s important to you,you will educate yourself ,while politicians,food producers and the medical/pharmaceutical industry continue to lie to the public-putting profits before health.

    Jenny,you are in a position to help people who really need and want it. Keep telling the truth, you may not have as many clients as the next guy but you will keep the strength of your convictions. We are vastly outnumbered by the excuse makers and spin doctors but that’s okay,don’t give in.

  • Anonymous

    Kids Wholesale Wearhouse was established in 2004 to provide wholesaler cheap ladies shoes a variety of kid’s clothing to resellers. They focus on wholesaler cheap men clothing providing a wholesaler cheap wholesaler cheap women shoes jewelry flexible wholesaler best bag service that allows resellers to order as much or as tiny as they require. All sizes of wholesaler cheap men clothing orders are wholesaler cheap ladies clothing handled in the same professional manner, from a single wholesale pack wholesaler best kid wholesaler cheap men shoes clothing through to a complete new store opening package.