So, You Think You’re Eating Healthy…

Consumer Reports Nutrition Quiz

Here’s a perplexing mathematical puzzle – If 2 out of 3 Americans are overweight or obese, how can it be that 9 out of 10 Americans (think they) are eating healthfully?

That’s what Consumer Reports wants to know, and a recent article explains why so many of us get it wrong:

We found that Americans are making an effort to practice good nutrition and weight control, with 90 percent describing their diet as “somewhat,” “very,” or “extremely” healthy. But they have a tendency to give themselves more credit than they perhaps deserve. They drink more sweetened beverages than they should, for example, and sometimes undercut their own efforts at weight control by not limiting their intake of sweets and fats.

Also, they like Cheerios a lot, but parsnips, not so much. Read the entire article…

What you need to know:

From our review of tens of thousands of nutrition labels, we’ve come to some conclusions as well:

#1 Many of us are simply clueless as to the nutritional value of what we eat. This is because packaged food products are designed to embellish the positive attributes of a product while obfuscating the negatives. Extreme examples: Soda pop is low-fat!!! Full fat beef is low-carb…

#2 Serving sizes are out of whack. Since nutrition fact labels show calorie information per serving, we are duped into thinking our calorie consumption is lower than it actually is. Examples: a serving of soda pop is one cup (8 fl oz) and has 90 calories. However, vending machines usually dispense 20 fl oz. bottles which we guzzle down to the tune of 225 calories! Other examples include a serving size of 2 cookies or 11 chips.

#3 It’s not enough to look at the calories and nutrients. Ingredient lists tell the story of the product. How much sugar has been added vs naturally present? Is the fiber real or fake? Just what did they add to the food when they took out the fat? Most people are not aware of all the additives in processed food. When we start eating fake, ultra-processed foods, our bodies react in unexpected ways, some which scientists are still trying to figure out. Example: some studies show that consumption of diet soft drinks actually increase the craving for sweet and thus overall caloric intake.

What to do at the supermarket:

Trust no brand and no product in the supermarket. The only way to know what you are actually going to be eating is to read the nutrition label and the ingredient list. Start with the serving size. Does it make sense? If it’s too small, then you’re actually consuming much more calories than you intended.

If you’d like to test your nutrition IQ, take this 5 question quiz from Consumer Reports.

Get Fooducated: iPhone App RSS Subscription or Email Subscription

Follow us on twitter: twitter.com/fooducate on facebook: facebook.com/fooducate

Get Fooducated

  • http://www.friedchickentotofu.com Poppy @ From Fried Chicken to Tofu

    Such a great point! Last year was the year I finally had my eyes opened to the fact that “fat free” may not necessarily be the most healthy choice. I think there are so many people being fooled by the front of the packaging when it comes to food. Dig deeper people! Turn that package over and check out the ingredients list for the REAL truth!

  • Corey

    Sweet potatoes are awesome! Superfoods IMO.

    http://www.sweetpotatoes.com

  • Connie

    or maybe it is the recommendations about what to eat aren’t really what we should be eating..

    http://www.amazon.com/Good-Calories-Bad-Gary-Taubes/dp/1400040787
    http://180degreehealth.blogspot.com/

  • http://www.UrbanOrganicGardener.com Mike Lieberman

    We need to get back to eating whole foods and step away from the processed stuff. Start by eating foods that don’t have labels. Start to grow some of your own. It’ll help you out in more ways that you could imagine.

  • http://www.betterschoolfood.org Dr. Susan Rubin

    I’m echoing @Mike Lieberman. Get out of the supermarket, go to the farmer’s market. Best bet: grow your own.

    All this nutrition silliness is like a giant game of Whack-a-mole
    http://www.drsusanrubin.com/food-industrys-favorite-game-whacamole/

  • candice

    Easy remedy: know your food! Processed food is pure crap, people are too busy to look past the glow-in-the-dark, radioactive colored processed food in the grocery stores. Corporations have harnessed our inability to turn away from something flashy and shiny and are exploiting us through the food we eat. If more people start making their own food from scratch, know their food and how it effects their bodies, they will be less inclined to pick up the imitation food.
    xo
    Candice
    http://www.theoldladyatheart.blogspot.com

  • http://www.foodieformerlyfat.com Foodie, Formerly Fat

    I love what you are saying about ingredient lists vs. nutritional labels. I agree 100%. But the survey from Consumer Reports is a bit strange to me. Quibbling over whether or not a banana or a sweet potato has more fiber; whether a bagel or donut from Dunkin Donuts has more calories; or whether baked beans or spinach have more fiber seems to be missing the point.

    I think it’s more simple than this: if you are eating bananas, sweet potatoes, and spinach you are on the right track. If you want to be healthy don’t eat anything from Dunkin Donuts. If you’re going to be eating baked beans make sure you are making them from scratch and not getting them from a can with ingredients that aren’t actually food.

    In the end it seems that knowing how to identify real food versus “edible food like substances” (and sticking with the real food) is going to be more impactful on your health than knowing off the top of your head if bananas or sweet potatoes have more fiber.