Planter’s Trail Mix – A Good Snack?

Jodie, who follows Fooducate on Facebook, asked – “can you let me know any information on Planters new Trail Mix? it’s delicious.. wondering if it’s too good to be good for me?”

Excellent question Jodie. Trail mix is a great mix of protein, heart healthy fats, and carbs that really helps keep people energized for hours on a trail.

A basic mix includes at least one type of nut or seed, with at least on kind of dried fruit. Example – peanuts and raisins – a starter kit!

There are endless combinations  you can create in your own kitchen, as well as prepackaged varieties out there. You have to watch out for added ingredients that you may not have counted on. Let’s take a look inside the label of Planter’s Trail Mix – Fruit & Nut flavor…

What you need to know:

Here is the ingredient list:

PEANUTS, RAISINS, BANANA CHIPS (BANANA, COCONUT OIL, SUGAR, NATURAL FLAVOR), SALTED CASHEWS (CASHEWS, PEANUT AND/OR COTTONSEED OIL, SALT), DRIED SWEETENED PINEAPPLE (PINEAPPLE, SUGAR, CITRIC ACID, PRESERVED WITH SULFUR DIOXIDE), DRIED SWEETENED CRANBERRIES (CRANBERRIES, SUGAR, SUNFLOWER OIL), DRIED SWEETENED PAPAYA (PAPAYA, SUGAR, CITRIC ACID, PRESERVED WITH SULFUR DIOXIDE). CONTAINS: PEANUT, CASHEW, SULFITES.

Let’s divide into 3 categories: seeds/nuts, fruit, all other:

1. seeds/nuts – peanuts, cashews

2. fruit – raisin, banana, pineapple, cranberries, papaya

3. other – coconut oil, sugar, natural flavor, oil, salt, more sugar, citric acid, sulfur dioxide, more sugar, more oil, more sugar, more citric acid, more sulfur dioxide.

If you were to make this product at home by buying the main ingredients in bulk, you would be perusing just 6 ingredients.

A 1 ounce serving is 140 calories, and contains 9 grams of fat, mostly unsaturated. The 10 grams of sugar (2 and a half teaspoons) come both from the fruit and the added sugars. The 15mg of sodium (less than 1% of the daily maximum) seems suspiciously low, especially since the cashews are salted. But if this is the true value, then great. In many instances, salted nuts can take your sodium intake ballistic. The protein count is OK at 3 grams.

Back to the ingredients.

Dried fruit is in most cases treated with sulfur dioxide to maintain its color. If you’ve ever bought organic dried apricots, you’ll remember the difference, as they look brown and unappealing compared to the bright and shiny orange apricots that contain the sulfites.

The added sugar is a shame. Dried fruit are sweet enough on their own, except maybe for cranberries.

The oil has 2 purposes – improve the flavor, and keep the various parts of the mix from clumping.

Bottom line: While a homemade version of this trail mix would reduce the number of unnecessary ingredients, overall this is a good snack.

What to do at the supermarket:

Look for the bulk bins and learn to craft your own trail mix. It’s much cheaper, real easy to do, and lets you fine tune the flavors to your specific taste.

Get Fooducated

  • Kate

    I have to disagree slightly with your statement that making this at home would involve only 6 ingredients. It’s very difficult to find unsweetened banana, papaya, pineapple, or cranberries in a typical store (even my excellent natural foods coop doesn’t always carry them). So, if you made this identical trail mix, the pineapple, papaya, and cranberries would still have sulfur dioxide, citric acid, and sugar in them, the banana chips would still have oil and sugar in them, and the salted cashews would still have oil and salt in them. You’d have almost exactly the same ingredients (except maybe the natural flavor in the banana chips). Unless you dry your own pineapple, cranberries, papaya, and banana, and roast your own cashews without added oil, you’re probably not going to do any better in terms of added ingredients making this yourself than buying it. It might be easier on your wallet to make it yourself, of course.

  • http://masteringpublichealth.wordpress.com/ Mastering Public Health (@MasPublicHealth)

    Good comment, Kate; however, this really does all depend on where one lives. In the New York City / metropolitan area, unsulfured/un-oiled dried fruit (even the exotic) is easily found in many natural foods stores. In general, though it’s frustrating how these “healthy” trail mixes confuse consumers into eating all kinds of sugars, additives, unnecessary oils, etc. Not to mention that most people are not aware of the extremely small portion sizes and multiple servings — per even the smallest bag — for trail mixes. The many that contain M&M candies also therefore boast artificial colors. If one can afford it, it’s most desirable to compile an organic trail mix (affordable options being Trader Joe’s Organic Trek Mix — they also have reasonably-priced organic raisins) which is free of chemical pesticides and will by default have fewer superfluous and harmful ingredients.

  • http://www.theomep.com Wet Wolf

    The problem with trail mix is that 99% of people don’t eat it while hiking in a trail up a mountain or in the woods. They pack it to munch on as a snack (AKA meal) in their cubicle at work.

    Combine the sedentary lifestyle of an office worker w/ an obesity issue + refined processed sugars + fats = a recipe for more fat gain.

    Solution- just eat an apple or some berries instead.

  • bill

    The sulfur in dried fruit can also have the effect of giving people headaches.

  • Tonyacz

    Wet Wolf is completely right. How many times are people eating this for a hike? Stick with a couple of Almonds and a piece of fruit.

  • Mel B

    @bill
    And for people with asthma, like myself, who have allergies to sulfides, this can cause a serious reaction.

  • Monica

    I only eat this when i go on hikes or have to be very active with not much time to eat.

  • http://www.theomep.com Wet Wolf

    @Monica
    Honestly I would not even suggest this before a hike. Like Tony mentioned just throw in some almonds along with an apple.

    Of you could try some walnuts mixed with blueberries.

  • http://foodtrainers.blogspot.com Lauren Slayton

    Ha, I’m just laughing that you gave something the thumbs up. I buy the Go Raw brand of dried figs/apricots. I’m not a sulfur dioxide fan.